Dienstag, 19. Juli 2011

Online gaming and betting: proposed new law in Germany criticised by the European Commission

Brussels, 19 July 2011

The European Commission today issued a ‘detailed opinion’ against the draft German State Gambling Treaty. This detailed opinion confirms that the Commission believes the proposed German State Treaty is in breach of EU law. If the draft is not substantially changed after this warning, Germany risks formal infringement proceedings, referral to the European Court of Justice (CJEU) and ultimately financial penalties.


The Commission has identified a number of provisions in the German draft State Gambling Treaty which are in conflict with the EU Treaty. While the draft law appears to open the market for online sports betting operators from all EU member states, it in practice reserves the market for the incumbent German monopolies. EGBA considers that several requirements in the draft State Treaty are in breach of EU law, including:

• The total number of sports betting licences available is limited without justification to seven (7), whereas the state monopoly for sports betting is exempt from the requirement to apply for a licence;
• An exorbitant tax of 16.67 percent of the amount wagered is imposed on all operators. This will make online wagering uneconomic, excluding online operators and is clearly intended to protect the current state monopoly on offline bets from online competition;
• The licensing system ‘bundles’ offline and online sports betting together and applies a commercial viability test to would-be operators, thus putting online-only operators at an automatic disadvantage in applying for a licence;
• While privately owned land-based premises are limited to 350 per license, no such restriction applies to outlets employed by the state-owned operators
• Certain casino games may be offered online but only by specified casino game operators that are already operating land-based casino games in Germany;
• An illegal expansion of marketing is encouraged for the state monopoly, but marketing restrictions are placed on other operators;
• The license fee will favour those applicants with land-based operations that attract higher margins and appears to be unrelated to the costs incurred to deliver and then maintain the license.

Sigrid Ligné, Secretary General of EGBA said today: ‘The draft German treaty has many provisions which are in conflict with EU law. But worse: it is clear that, taken together and especially including a prohibitive tax on wagers from which the incumbent state monopoly is exempt, these provisions effectively slam the door in the face of EU operators from other member states and will in fact extend the monopoly for offline to online games. The Commission must act quickly to stop this test case for its stated aim of a common EU framework for this sector ’.

The proposed German State Gambling Treaty comes after a number of preliminary rulings by the EU Court that the current State Treaty is incompatible with EU law (see inter alia Carmen Media, C- 46/08). The current law expires at the end of 2011 and the intention was to have the new treaty to come into force in January 2012.

In Germany the regions, or Länder, are competent for lotteries and sports betting while casinos and slot machines are the competence of the federal state. There is however no agreement between the Länder on this draft treaty on sports betting. Schleswig Holstein has already notified an alternative gambling law that will foster a commercially viable sports betting market for EU-licensed operators, thereby removing the attractions of the black market for consumers. The Commission raised no objections to such law and EGBA remains fully supportive of the efforts to enact it.

According to a study by Gold Media, the gross online gaming and betting revenue in Germany was €1 billion in 2009, with a 30 percent annual growth rate (1). Online gaming is a large and vibrant segment of the digital economy in Germany. Whilst material, failing to comply with EU law is only one of the major issues with the proposed State Gambling Treaty. The draft Treaty, if enacted as proposed will simply drive consumers into the hands of black market operators that will not deliver the same levels of consumer protection, that will reduce visibility of the online gaming and betting market in Germany and will forego the opportunity to raise tax revenue.

(1) http://www.goldmedia.com/en/press/newsroom/
study-betting-and-gambling-in-germany.html

For further information or comment please contact:
Sigrid Ligné: +32 2 554 08 90
Sigrid.Ligne@egba.eu

About EGBA
The EGBA is an association of leading European gaming and betting operators Bet-at-home.com, BetClic, bwinparty, Digibet, Expekt, Interwetten, and Unibet. EGBA is a Brussels-based non-profit association. It promotes the right of private gaming and betting operators that are regulated and licensed in one Member State to a fair market access throughout the European Union. Online gaming and betting is a fast growing market, but will remain for the next decades a limited part of the overall European gaming market in which the traditional land based offer is expected to grow from € 79.6 Billion GGR in 2009 to € 83 Billion GGR in 2012, thus keeping the lion’s share with 87% of the market. Source: H2 Gambling Capital, April 2010

The Notification Procedure

Under Directive 98/34/EC, Member States must notify to the European Commission and other Member States draft regulations regarding products and Information Society services such as online gaming and betting, before adopting them. This procedure is aimed at preventing Member States from creating new barriers to the internal market freedoms by giving the opportunity to the Commission and Member States to evaluate the content of a draft law before it is adopted.

The notification of a text to the Commission opens a three month standstill period during which the draft text must not be adopted. This period allows the Commission and Member States to ascertain whether the draft text presents any unjustified barriers to the internal market. The Commission and/or Member States may then issue:
• a detailed opinion, if they consider that the draft text would, if implemented, create barriers to trade, services or establishment within the EU;
• comments, if they consider that the text raises issues of interpretation or requires further details; or
• no response, if they consider that the text is compatible with EU law.
A detailed opinion attempts to prevent Members States from adopting a text, which contains barriers to the internal market, or to urge them to remove the restrictive provisions, thereby avoiding unnecessary legislative work and future EU infringement proceedings.

Once a detailed opinion had been issued, the standstill period, during which the draft text must not be adopted, is extended by one month. If, after this time, the draft text is adopted without modification, the Commission can immediately commence an infringement procedure against the Member State’s newly adopted legislation.

To access the TRIS database and search for other draft laws see:
http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/tris/pisa/app/search/index.cfm?lang=EN

Donnerstag, 30. Juni 2011

EGBA: CJEU questions consistency of French gambling law

Brussels, 30 June 2011

The European Court today ruled once again that a monopoly can only be justified if findings prove that gambling related problems actually exist and a particularly high level of consumer protection is granted. This ruling, which concerns the former law, also adds pressure on the current French gambling legislation that was introduced in May 2010.

The European Gaming and Betting Association (EGBA) welcomes today’s ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) stating once again that an EU Member State is not permitted to close its gambling market on public policy grounds while, at the same time, allowing its own monopoly operator to employ aggressive marketing encouraging consumers to play substantially more without evidencing that such marketing can effectively solve gambling related problems (Zeturf case C-212/08, para 70).

Since the French legislator has not considered it necessary to make a distinction between land-based and online distribution channels at the time of the referral, the national courts must assess the consistent and systematic approach of the French legislation as regards the entire horserace betting sector both online and offline.

In particular the CJEU insists that the French jurisdiction verifies whether:
• “the national authorities genuinely sought, at the material time, to ensure such a particularly high level of protection and whether, having regard to the level of protection sought, the establishment of a monopoly could actually be considered necessary” (para.47),
• “the State controls to which the activities of the body benefiting from the exclusive rights are, in principle, subject are actually implemented in the consistent and systematic pursuit of the objectives assigned to that body” (para.72);
• The monopoly is “based on a finding that criminal and fraudulent activities linked to gaming and gambling addiction are a problem in the territory of the Member State concerned, which the expansion of authorised and regulated activities would be capable of solving“(para.72);
• “only advertising that is measured and strictly limited to what is necessary in order to channel consumers towards controlled gaming networks” (para.71) is allowed, already having established that “the PMU makes use of sustained and growing advertising for its products, including on the internet, and is increasing the number of outlets for betting and for the products offered to bettors. It uses, moreover, a commercial strategy that seeks to draw in new audiences for the betting offered” (para.65). (1)

Sigrid Ligné, Secretary General of the EGBA said: ´Today´s ruling confirms that Member States have to choose between either a monopoly with policies which are genuinely designed to reduce gambling opportunities or a well regulated market where also EU operators can provide their services. It is a clear question of consistency.´

The Zeturf case concerns French legislation which has changed since the case was referred by the French Conseil d’Etat – the highest administrative Court – to the CJEU and thus no longer applies, but civil and criminal proceedings are nevertheless still being pursued against the Zeturf Limited, an EU licensed and regulated company providing online gambling services. Now that the CJEU has given clear indications that the former law is not in compliance with EU law, these proceedings are likely to be dropped after an assessment by the national court.

Several complaints against the new French law of May 2010, partially regulating the online gambling market, are still pending both in France and at the European Commission. Separately, the Commission has already opened a State aid investigation against the French parafiscal levy on online horse-race betting, the decision on which is expected in the second half of 2011 (State aid case C 34/10).

Footnote:
(1) Underscore added

For further information or comment please contact:
Sigrid Ligné: +32 2 554 08 99
Sigrid.Ligne@egba.eu

Donnerstag, 24. März 2011

EGBA concerned at EC Green Paper on online gambling

Brussels, 24 March 2011

The European Gaming and Betting Association (EGBA) welcomes today’s publication of the Green Paper on online gambling that will allow for a factual discussion at EU level. At the same time, the EGBA expresses its concern with the apparent lack of commitment to curb further fragmentation of the common market and ensure that consumers throughout the EU enjoy consistent standards of regulated, safe and high-quality products.

Without clear EU framework rules, the European online gambling market, estimated at € 9.08 billion in 2011 (1), risks being driven underground into the hands of black market operators to the detriment of consumers, legitimate EU licensed operators and State finances.

Secretary General of EGBA Sigrid Ligné said: “We welcome the Commission coming forward with a Green Paper and a factual discussion on all aspects of online gambling. We are deeply concerned though that the focus of the paper seems to be on a national rather than an EU approach despite the clear cross-border nature of this sector. What we expect is the Commission to propose an EU regulatory framework for online gambling, as it has done for other inherently highly regulated sectors such as telecoms or pharmaceuticals. In parallel, the Commission in its role as guardian of the Treaty should vigorously and systematically pursue infringement proceedings against those Member States that continue to violate EU law.”

The EGBA’s main comments on the Green Paper are the following:

• The Commission rightly devotes much attention to the questions of consumer protection and prevention of fraud. Indeed as confirmed by the Commission, the Internet offers unique opportunities ‘as it provides the operators with more sophisticated possibilities to track the transactions of each player compared to off-line gambling formats’. Valuable initiatives have been developed in these areas, most recently by the European standards body CEN, which issued a workshop agreement on ‘Responsible Remote Gambling Measures’ on 24 February, setting out a list of 134 concrete measures that ensure responsible gambling and provide greater protection for consumers throughout the EU.

• Unfortunately the Commission is silent on the need for hard EU rules to combat the increasing fragmentation of the Internal Market through uncoordinated national prohibitions and restrictions. Yet, as the Commission itself admits: ‘The development of internet and the increased supply of online gambling services have made it more difficult for the different national regulatory models to co-exist.’

• The cost of this fragmentation and duplication of national requirements is particularly high. A study conducted in 2010 by Price Waterhouse Coopers shows that, for France alone, the administrative and technical costs for obtaining and maintaining the national licence to operate on the French market are € 8.7 million for a single EU operator, already licensed in one or several other Member States. National licensing regimes imposing such burdens on the service providers only benefit non-EU licensed black market operators to the detriment of player protection.

• Go-it-alone national rule-making risks being at odds with the jurisprudence of the CJEU, which sets clear limits to restrictions that can be imposed on legitimate EU operators, and may infringe competition rules. Between 2006 and 2010, over 150 national draft acts and laws have been notified to the Commission for single market screening, and many have received a formal warning from the Commission for not complying with EU law. Infringement cases have been commenced against several national laws put in force despite the Commission’s early warning. However, since early 2008 no developments have taken place in the pending infringement cases and no new infringement proceedings have been opened.

Sigrid Ligné concluded: ´The launch of this Green Paper should under no circumstances cause the Commission to freeze pending or avoid opening new infringement cases against national regulations that are in violation of the Treaty.´

---------------------------------------------------------
(1) H2 Gambling Capital March 2011 (EU 27)

For further information or comment please contact:
Sigrid Ligné: +32 2 554 08 90
Sigrid.Ligne@egba.eu

About EGBA
The European Gaming and Betting Association is an association of leading European gaming and betting operators Bet-at-home.com, BetClic, bwin, Digibet, Expekt, Interwetten, PartyGaming and Unibet. EGBA is a Brussels-based non-profit association. It promotes the right of private gaming and betting operators that are regulated and licensed in one Member State to a fair market access throughout the European Union. Online gaming and betting is a fast growing market, but will remain for the next decades a limited part of the overall European gaming market in which the traditional land based offer is expected to grow from € 79.6 Billion GGR in 2009 to € 83.7 Billion GGR in 2012, thus keeping the lion’s share with 87% of the market. Source: H2 Gambling Capital, April 2010.

Dienstag, 1. Februar 2011

Principality of Liechtenstein: Call for Tenders for a Casino License

by Attorney-at-Law Martin Arendts, M.B.L.-HSG

The new Gambling Act (Geldspielgesetz - GSG) and the Casino Ordinance (Spielbankenverordnung - SPBV) of the Principality of Liechtenstein allow the operation of a casino. Today, the government authorised the call for tenders. Until an evaluation report will be published, only one license will be granted. Applications for the license have to be filed by 31 March 2011, 4:30 p.m. tender documents can be requested from Amt für Volkswirtschaft for a fee of SFR 2.000,-.

Mittwoch, 13. Oktober 2010

Regulated online gaming industry calls for full EU harmonisation

Brussels, 13 October 2010 – Europe will gain from harmonised EU rules governing the gaming sector. That’s the message delivered by Norbert Teufelberger, Co-CEO of bwin, to a packed audience today in the European Parliament at the 3rd “Responsible Gaming Day” (RGD).

Organised by the European Gaming and Betting Association (EGBA), the body representing the licensed EU industry, this year’s RGD - entitled “Responsible Gaming in a digital single market” - brought together over 150 delegates including senior EU and national officials, representatives from the public and private gaming sectors, academia and civil society to discuss the state of play in EU and national gaming regulation.

Norbert Teufelberger, Co-CEO of bwin and chairman of the EGBA, continued: “With almost 2/3 of EU member states already working on or at least considering a reform of their gaming markets, there is a unique momentum now to ensure that regulation delivers for consumers, the industry and Europe. Regulation must be harmonised so that consumers receive similar high protection regardless of where they play. Online gaming is a cross-border activity and consumer protection needs to be applied cross-border as well”.

Speaking on behalf of the European Commission, Jean Bergevin, head of unit at DG Internal Market, said: “The Commission is determined to proceed with an objective and factual basis consultation at the earliest by the end of the year in the form of a green paper which will collect the information necessary to determine the most efficient and coherent systems addressing recognized public interest objectives”.

Host of the event in the European Parliament, Timothy Kirkhope, MEP added: “This is a golden opportunity to begin to set in place a level playing field for a sector which is struggling with a patchwork of different rules. I have great faith in Commissioner Barnier that that he will take heed of our discussions today, and begin to work out a strategy to ensure that online gambling can become a legitimate part of the internal market.”

For further information or comment please contact:
Sigrid Ligné: +32 2 554 08 90
Sigrid.Ligne@egba.eu

Mittwoch, 8. September 2010

EGBA: Online gaming: Time for change in Europe

In landmark ruling the ECJ concludes that the German sports betting and lotteries monopoly is unjustified and inconsistent

Brussels, 8 September 2010

Three preliminary rulings(1) handed down today by the European Court of Justice confirm that the “German rules do not limit games of chance in a consistent and systematic manner” and stresses that “national rules concerning that monopoly, held to be contrary to the fundamental freedoms of the Union, cannot continue to apply during the time necessary to bring it into conformity with (European) Union law” (ECJ press release 78/10).

The Court stresses in particular that “the holders of public monopolies carry out intensive advertising campaigns with a view to maximize profit from lotteries thereby departing from the objectives justifying the existence of those monopolies” (ECJ press release 78/10) .

The Interstate Treaty on Gambling that came into force in 2008 and was supposed to expire at the end of 2011 currently bans online gaming and betting activities in the country. In a recent study Gold Media concluded that the ban had no effect on the yearly 30% growth in consumer demand for online gaming and betting in Germany, but rather had pushed the consumer to portals operated outside of Germany. (2)

The ECJ rulings come at a time of intense political debate in Germany and other European countries on the existing gaming legislation. “More and more stakeholders are raising concerns with regard to the efficiency of a ban on online gaming and are calling on the government to overturn the Interstate Treaty. Their arguments will be bolstered by today´s rulings”, said Sigrid Ligné, Secretary General of the European Gaming and Betting Association.

“When it comes to consumer protection, the prohibition of online gaming makes no sense. As a matter of fact, online gaming and betting is a popular leisure activity for millions of people. Neither a total ban nor a state monopoly are suitable to meet the aim of protecting consumers”, added Sigrid Ligné.

"There is a need for a political solution that does justice to the demand of consumers to play online and that at the same time ensures a high level of consumer protection. Other Member States have opened or are opening their markets and moving away from a monopoly regime to a multi-operator licensing system. They show that consumers can be better protected in a market that is both regulated and open to competition. It is now up to German politicians to draw the appropriate conclusions and take their responsibility towards their consumers”, said Sigrid Ligné.

- - -

1 C-409/06, C-46/08, C-316/07
2 http://www.goldmedia.com/uploads/media/Pressemeldung_Goldmedia_Gluecksspiel_Deutschland.pdf

Dienstag, 27. Juli 2010

right2bet: EU CONSUMERS LEFT DRASTICALLY SHORT-CHANGED BY STATE GAMBLING MONOPOLIES

RIGHT2BET has exclusively revealed that throughout the World Cup European state betting monopolies offered their customers, on average, 32% worse odds than those available with private betting companies.

Monopoly customers wishing to back their home nation in South Africa were subjected to 35% worse odds than those being offered by the EU-licensed private sector operators that their governments do not allow them to use.

The startling figures have been revealed in the Right2bet World Cup Report which analysed the odds offered on every World Cup match by seven of Europe's biggest betting monopolies, before comparing them to the equivalent prices being offered by other licensed European operators.

The aim of the report was to investigate whether or not Europe's betting monopolies were short-changing their customers via the help of legislation which protects their existence and market dominance.

Right2bet is campaigning for the right of all European consumers to be able to bet with the licensed operator of their choice, regardless of the Member State in which they are based.

Right2bet spokesman Ari Last said: "The figures emanating from this report are quite shocking. Millions of EU consumers who wanted to bet during the World Cup were subjected to hugely inferior prices by the monopolies that their governments strive so hard to protect."

"The protectionist behaviour of certain Member States when it comes to online gambling is a situation that does not conform to the ethos of the single-market, and we hope that the findings of this report will highlight what is undoubtedly an unjust reality."

Right2bet World Cup Report key points:

• Monopolies offered their customers 32% worse odds than licensed private operators
• The 'Perfect Bettor' forced to bet with a monopoly would have made €629 less than they would have done if they were allowed to bet with other EU-licensed operators in the private sector
• On average, a monopoly customer choosing to back the 'favourite' throughout every one of the 64 tournament matches would have received 38% less value, while one who chose to back the 'outsider' throughout each game of the tournament would have received 35% less value
• Monopolies offered customers wishing to back their home nation 35% worse odds than private operators
• It is clear from the results published in this report that consumers using online gambling services in the EU are receiving significantly lower value when forced to use a state monopoly provider

Country breakdowns:

• Germany: 48% worse off
• Sweden: 40% worse off
• The Netherlands: 35% worse off
• France: 31.5% worse off
• Greece: 31% worse off
• Denmark: 14.4% worse off

Samstag, 24. Juli 2010

Referral to ECJ from UK with regard to the taxation of FOBTs ("Rank Group")

Reference for a preliminary ruling from The Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) (United Kingdom) made on 26 May 2010 - Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs v The Rank Group PLC

(Case C-260/10)

Language of the case: English

Referring court

The Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) (United Kingdom)

Parties to the main proceedings

Applicant: Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs

Defendant: The Rank Group PLC

Questions referred

Where a Member State in the exercise of its discretion under Article 13B(f) of the Sixth VAT Directive1 subjected certain types of machines used for gambling ("Part III gaming machines") to VAT, while retaining exemption for other such machines (which included fixed odds betting terminals, "FOBTs"), and where it is contended that in so doing the Member State infringed the principle of fiscal neutrality: is it

(i) determinative, or (ii) relevant, when comparing Part III gaming machines and FOBTs that

(a) FOBTs offered activities that were "betting" under domestic law (or activities that the relevant regulatory authority, for the purposes of exercising its regulatory powers, was prepared to treat as "betting" under domestic law)

and

(b) Part III gaming machines offered activities subject to a different classification under domestic law, namely "gaming" and that gaming and betting were subject to different regulatory regimes under that Member State's law relating to the control and regulation of gambling? If so, what are the differences between the regulatory regimes in question to which the national court should have regard?

In determining whether the principle of fiscal neutrality requires the same tax treatment of the types of machine referred to in Question 1 (FOBTs and Part III gaming machines), what level of abstraction should be adopted by the national court in determining whether the products are similar? In particular, to what extent is it relevant to take into account the following matters:

a. similarities and differences in the permitted maximum stakes and prizes as between FOBTs and Part III gaming machines;

b. that FOBTs could be played only on certain types of premises licensed for betting, which were different, and subject to regulatory constraints that were different from those applicable to, premises licensed for gaming (although FOBTs and up to two Part III gaming machines could be played alongside each other in premises licensed for betting);

c. that the chances of winning the prize on FOBTs were directly related to the published fixed odds, whereas the chances of winning on Part III gaming machines could in some cases be varied by a device that ensured a particular percentage return to the operator and player over time;

d. similarities and differences in the formats available on FOBTs and Part III gaming machines;

e. similarities and differences as between FOBTs and Part III gaming machines in the interaction which could occur between the player and the machine;

f. whether or not the matters referred to above were either known to the generality of players of the machines or regarded by them as relevant or important;

g. whether the difference in VAT treatment is justified by any of the above?

In a situation where a Member State, in the exercise of its discretion under Article 13B(f) of the Sixth VAT Directive, exempted gambling from VAT but subjected a defined class of machines used for gambling to VAT: -

a) is there in principle a defence of due diligence available to a Member Sate to a claim that the principle of fiscal neutrality has been infringed by that Member Sate; and

b) if the answer to (a) is "yes", what factors are relevant in determining whether or not the Member Sate is entitled to rely on that defence?
____________

1 - Sixth Council Directive 77/388/EEC of 17 May 1977 on the harmonization of the laws of the Member States relating to turnover taxes - Common system of value added tax: uniform basis of assessment OJ L 145, p. 1

And yet another referral to the ECJ from Italy with regard to the cross-border provision of sports betting ("Minesi")

Reference for a preliminary ruling from the Tribunale del Riesame di Verbania (Italy) lodged on 4 June 2010 - Criminal proceedings against Matteo Minesi

(Case C-279/10)

Language of the case: Italian

Referring court

Tribunale del Riesame di Verbania

Party to the main proceedings

Matteo Minesi

Question referred

The Court of Justice is requested to interpret Articles 43 and 49 of the Treaty establishing the European Union with reference to freedom of establishment and freedom to provide services in the sector of betting on sports events in order to establish whether or not those Treaty provisions permit national rules establishing a State monopoly and a system of licences and authorisations which, within the context of a given number of licences:

(a) tend generally to protect holders of licences issued at an earlier period on the basis of a procedure that unlawfully excluded some operators;

(b) in fact ensure the maintenance of commercial positions acquired following a procedure that unlawfully excluded certain operators (by, for example, prohibiting new licensees from locating their kiosks within a specified distance of those already in existence);

(c) provide cases in which the licence may lapse with forfeiture of very large guarantee deposits, including the case in which the licensee directly or indirectly carries on cross-border gaming activities analogous to those under the licence.

New referral to the ECJ from Italy with regard to the cross-border provision of sports betting ("Sacci")

Reference for a preliminary ruling from the Tribunale di Roma (Italy), made on 23 March 2010 - Criminal proceedings against Alessandro Sacchi

(Case C-255/10)

Language of the case: Italian

Referring court

Tribunale di Roma

Party to the main proceedings

Alessandro Sacchi

Question referred

What interpretation is to be given to Articles 43 EC and 49 EC with reference to freedom of establishment and freedom to provide services in the sector of betting on sports events, regard being had also to the principle of effective judicial protection, in order to establish whether or not those Treaty provisions permit national rules establishing a State monopoly and a system of licences and authorisations which, within the context of a given number of licences,:

(a) tend generally to protect holders of licences issued at an earlier period on the basis of a procedure that unlawfully excluded certain operators;

(b) ensure the de facto maintenance of commercial positions acquired at the conclusion of a procedure that unlawfully excluded certain operators (by, for example, prohibiting new licensees from locating their betting outlets within a specified distance from those already in existence);

(c) lay down cases in which the licence may lapse, with forfeiture of large guarantee deposits, including the case in which the licensee directly or indirectly carries on cross-border gaming activities analogous to those under the licence?

Dienstag, 20. Juli 2010

Online gaming and betting: Polish draft legislation fails EU screening test

The European Commission issued yesterday a detailed opinion against the Polish draft legislation regulating online gaming and betting. The Polish draft legislation also raised concerns among a number of Member States such as the United Kingdom and Malta.

Sigrid Ligné, Secretary General of EGBA said: “We support the Polish government’s intention to join the growing number of countries regulating the online gaming and betting market in the EU. However, the current draft foresees a wide range of obstacles and obligations which will make it highly difficult for EU licensed and regulated operators to apply for a license in Poland. We urge Poland to revise its draft and align it with the requirements of the EU Treaty.”

According to the EGBA, a number of key provisions in the draft are highly doubtful under EU law. This includes:

- the requirement for licensees to be established in Poland either in the form of a joint stock company or in the form of a limited company with a very high share capital

- the possibility to exclude companies whose shares are quoted on the stock exchanges

- the requirement for online betting companies to install and store their servers in Poland

- the obligation for all transactions related to the betting services to be carried out through a Polish bank or in a branch of a foreign bank established in Poland

- the unjustified exclusion of certain games such as online poker

- the huge differences (in terms of financial guarantees and license fees) required for online and offline operators

“Some of these provisions seem to stem from a legitimate wish to regulate and enforce the rules for the online gaming market but they duplicate requirements already fulfilled in other jurisdictions. EU licensed and regulated companies can fulfill all necessary requirements on fraud prevention and consumer protection without being necessarily established in Poland. This draft law would leave Polish consumers without a fair, secure and competitive online gaming market” added Sigrid Ligné.

In addition, some of the provisions such as the licensing requirements and advertising restrictions also beg the question as to whether the law will be economically attractive for EU licensed operators. The Polish draft law was notified to the European Commission and Member States on 14 April 2010. Today’s detailed opinion extends the standstill period until 16 August, during which time Poland cannot adopt its draft legislation. Poland is required to reply to the Commission’s views. If Poland fails to take into account the Commission’s objections, the Commission can immediately launch infringement proceedings.

press release of EGBA

Freitag, 9. Juli 2010

ECJ: Judgment in Joined Cases C-447/08 and C-448/08 - Criminal proceedings against Otto Sjöberg and Anders Gerdin

Court of Justice of the European Union
PRESS RELEASE No 75/10
Luxembourg, 8 July 2010

Swedish legislation which prohibits the promotion of gambling organised on the Internet by private operators in other Member States for profit is consistent with Community law

However, Community law precludes national legislation which penalises the promotion of gambling organised in Sweden without a licence differently from that of gambling organised outside Sweden


Swedish legislation on gambling prohibits and penalises the promotion in Sweden of gambling organised outside that Member State. It reserves the right to organise gambling to operators pursuing socially beneficial objectives or those which are in the public interest.

Mr Sjöberg and Mr Gerdin were the editors in chief and publishers, respectively, of the Swedish newspapers Expressen and Aftonbladet. Between November 2003 and August 2004, they published on the sports pages of their newspapers advertisements for gambling offered on the Internet sites of the companies Expekt, Unibet, Ladbrokes and Centrebet, established in Malta and the United Kingdom. On the basis of those facts, considered to infringe the Swedish law on gambling, they were each sentenced to a criminal penalty of a fine of SEK 50 000 (approximately EUR 5 200) at first instance.

The Svea hovrätt (Stockholm Court of Appeal, Sweden), which must rule on the appeals brought by Mr Sjöberg and Mr Gerdin, questions whether the legislation on which the convictions are based and, more specifically, the provisions which fix the penalties applicable to promotion in Sweden of gambling organised outside that Member State, comply with Community law.

In today’s judgment, the Court observes first of all that Community law requires the abolition of all restrictions on the freedom to provide services, even if those restrictions apply without distinction to national providers of services and to those from other Member States, when they are liable to prohibit, impede or render less advantageous the activities of a service provider established in another Member State where it lawfully provides similar services.

The Court states that the effect of the Swedish legislation, which prohibits the promotion in Sweden both of gambling organised legally in other Member States and of unlicensed gambling in Sweden, is to restrict Swedish consumers’ participation in such gambling.

However, Community law allows restrictions justified, inter alia, on grounds of public policy, public security or public health. In the absence of harmonisation at European Union level as regards gambling, it is for each Member State to determine in that area, in accordance with its own scale of values, how to protect the interests in question. The Member States are therefore free to set the objectives of their policy on gambling and, where appropriate, to define in detail the level of protection sought. The restrictive measures that they impose must nevertheless satisfy the conditions laid down in the case-law of the Court as regards their proportionality and it is necessary to examine in particular whether the Swedish legislation is suitable for achieving the legitimate objective or objectives invoked by that Member State, and whether it does not go beyond what is necessary in order to achieve those objectives.

The Court observes that it is clear that the exclusion of private profit-making interests from the gambling sector is, according to the referring court, a fundamental principle of the Swedishlegislation in this field. Those activities are reserved in Sweden to bodies pursuing objectives which are socially beneficial or in the public interest and licences for the operation of gambling have been granted exclusively to public or charitable bodies.

The Court states in this connection that considerations of a cultural, moral or religious nature can justify restrictions on the freedom of gambling operators to provide services, in particular in so far as it might be considered unacceptable to allow private profit to be drawn from the exploitation of a social evil or the weakness of players and their misfortune. According to the scale of values held by each of the Member States and having regard to the discretion available to them, a Member State may restrict the operation of gambling by entrusting it to public or charitable bodies.

Since the gaming operators which caused the advertisements on account of which the criminal proceedings in the main actions were initiated to be published are private undertakings run for profit, which could never have obtained licences for the operation of gambling under Swedish legislation, the Court concludes that the Swedish legislation reflects the objective of the exclusion of private profit-making interests from the gambling sector and may be regarded as necessary in order to meet such an objective. Community law therefore does not preclude such legislation.

Next, the Court notes that the Swedish law referred to by the Svea hovrätt provides for criminal sanctions only in relation to the promotion of gambling organised in another Member State and does not apply to the promotion of gambling organised in Sweden without a licence, that latter offence being punishable only by an administrative penalty. It observes, however, that there is a disagreement between the Swedish Government, on the one hand, and Mr Sjöberg and Mr Gerdin, on the other, on the issue of whether another Swedish law provides for penalties for the promotion of gambling organised in Sweden without a licence which are equivalent to those applied in respect of the promotion of gambling organised in another Member State.

The Court points out that, in the context of these proceedings, the interpretation of provisions of national law is a matter for the courts of the Member States, not for the Court of Justice. Consequently, it is for the referring court to examine whether the two infringements at issue, although covered by different laws, are nevertheless subject to equivalent treatment. That court must in particular ascertain whether, on the facts, those infringements are prosecuted by the competent authorities with the same diligence and culminate in the imposition of equivalent penalties by the competent courts.

Thus, the Court concludes that, if the two infringements at issue receive equivalent treatment, the national legislation cannot be regarded as discriminatory. On the other hand, if the persons carrying out the promotion of gambling organised in Sweden without a licence incur penalties which are less strict than those imposed on the persons who advertise gambling organised in other Member States, then the Swedish arrangements are discriminatory and thus infringe Community law.

Dienstag, 8. Juni 2010

bwin lands online gaming licenses in France

France regulates online gaming market and awards bwin sports betting and poker licenses in time for the Football World Cup

Vienna – As one of the first operators, bwin, the world's leading online gaming provider, has been granted French online gaming licenses. Issued by the French regulator ARJEL, the online sports betting license entitles the French subsidiary bwin Entertainment Services (B.E.S. SAS) to offer online sports betting to French customers starting on 9 June 2010. In obtaining this license, all the requirements have been met to ensure the timely launch of a French label just before the Football World Cup. "We were confident throughout that we would be able to start off in a regulated French market before the World Cup kick-off. In obtaining the license, we have successfully jumped the biggest hurdle," says Norbert Teufelberger, Co-CEO of bwin Interactive Entertainment AG. Preparations for the launch of bwin.fr are all complete.

Along with the license for sports betting, B.E.S. SAS was also awarded a poker license. The poker license will become valid as soon as the requisite legal conditions have been established in France. As a result, real-money poker will presumably be available on the French label bwin.fr starting end of June.

Law: Important first step
"We are pleased that, following Italy, another country has followed the call for a clearly regulated and transparent market. The present law is a great first step. There are still a few more miles to go on the road toward establishing legal conditions that warrant fair competition in France. We will be working closely together with the French authorities in order to take these developments forward," says Norbert Teufelberger.

Joint venture SAjOO also obtains sports betting and poker licenses
There is nothing more to stop the start of sajoo.fr in the next few days. SAjOO, a joint venture uniting bwin and the French media group Éditions Philippe Amaury (Amaury Group), has also been issued a provider license by the French regulator. "With our dual-brand strategy, bwin is all set to take on a leading role in the newly regulated French online gaming market," says Norbert Teufelberger.

Montag, 7. Juni 2010

Online gambling: barriers removed in Italy

IP/10/504

Brussels, 5 May 2010

The European Commission has ensured that Italian citizens will have access to a wider choice of authorised on-line gambling services as a result of changes made to Italy's laws on online gambling. The Commission has therefore closed a series of legal cases against Italy concerning this legislation. The Commission had previously found that Italy's restrictions on foreign operators were disproportionate and had started legal proceedings against Italy for breaching EU rules on the freedom to provide services. Following the Commission's legal action, the Italian authorities engaged in an open and constructive dialogue with the Commission and amended its on-line gambling legislation.

Before Italy changed its law, the Italian Olympic Committee (CONI) and the National Horse Breeders Enhancement Society (UNIRE) had the exclusive right to organise sports betting, including online gambling. As a result, other legitimate European gambling operators could not offer their online services in Italy. Moreover, access to their web sites was effectively blocked from Italy.

While EU law permits Member States to restrict the offering of gambling services in the public interest, for example to prevent gambling addiction or organised crime, such restrictions must be coherent with the Member State's own behaviour in offering the very same services. Furthermore, any measures taken by Member States to restrict the market have to be necessary, proportionate and non-discriminatory. Acting upon a complaint, the Commission found that Italy's restrictions on foreign service providers and measures to block access to the web sites at that time were disproportionate. As a result, the Commission started infringement proceedings against Italy in 2006 (IP/06/436 and IP/06/1362).

How will citizens and businesses now benefit?

With its new law, Italy has now opened its online gambling market. Citizens in Italy will now have a broader choice of online gambling services for sports betting, which will continue to be authorised and supervised by the Italian authorities. Meanwhile, other European gambling operators will have the possibility to apply for Italian licences and offer their services in Italy. Nevertheless, gambling will continue to be safeguarded in the general interest in order to protect vulnerable consumers and to prevent gambling addiction as well as criminal activities.

Background

The Commission acted upon receiving a complaint in 2003. After investigating the case, the Commission started infringement proceedings against Italy in 2006 by sending a letter of formal notice, the first stage of an infringement procedure. Following an open and constructive dialogue between the Commission and the Italian authorities, Italy notified the Commission in 2009 it had amended its laws. The Commission welcomes the new Italian law that will allow for the cross border provision of services, with clear rules for the authorisation and the granting of licences to domestic and European operators and has decided to close the case.

More information on the Commission's legal cases against Member States is available at:

http://ec.europa.eu/community_law/index_en.htm

Donnerstag, 3. Juni 2010

ECJ rules on Dutch gambling laws: Industry calls on the European Commission to propose legislation at EU level

Today, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) rendered two preliminary rulings (1) addressing key questions relating to the compliance of the Dutch legislation with the EU Treaty. The cases (C-203/08 and C-258/08) at stake originate in national proceedings involving Ladbrokes and Betfair, two companies, established in the UK.

Sigrid Ligné, Secretary General of the EGBA, said: “The Court has confirmed that if a Member State wants to prohibit or channel gambling through a single operator it has to comply with strict features that we consider are clearly not met in the context of the Dutch legislation. But it is now for the national judge to assess the consistency of the Dutch gambling policy and to make a final decision”.

She adds: “Internet raises new questions and challenges that cannot be resolved through the judicial process. It is for the European legislator to ensure that this IT-based medium which allows for the highest security standards warrants consistent customer protection and fraud control throughout the EU.”

As confirmed by the Internal Market Commissioner Barnier, there is momentum to take action at EU level in the context of a Green Paper (2) and - whenever necessary - through infringement procedures (3) against Member States that do not comply with EU law.

Sigrid Ligné concludes: “We are confident that reform of the gambling laws will take place in the Netherlands, as they already do throughout the EU. Beyond the legal considerations, you also have to look at the reality of the market. There is a consumer demand for online gaming in the Netherlands, like there is all over Europe. Increasingly, EU Member States like Italy, Denmark and France realize that online gaming is a popular leisure activity and are opening their market to competition. EGBA urges the Dutch authorities to also start regulating the market.”

In line with previous case law, the ECJ confirms that under certain strict circumstances a monopoly can be allowed to promote its offer for the purpose of fraud prevention. However, according to the ECJ:

• If the Netherlands is “pursuing a policy of substantially expanding betting and gaming, by excessively inciting and encouraging consumers to participate in such activities (…) it would have to be concluded that such a policy does not limit betting and gaming activities in a consistent and systematic manner and is not, therefore, suitable for achieving the objective of curbing consumer addiction to such activities” (Ladbrokes, case C-258/08, 28)

• "Since the objective of protecting consumers from gambling addiction is, in principle, difficult to reconcile with a policy of expanding games of chance characterised, inter alia, by the creation of new games and by the advertising of such games, such a policy cannot be regarded as being consistent unless the scale of unlawful activity is significant and the measures adopted are aimed at channeling consumers’ propensity to gamble into activities that are lawful” (Idem, point 30)

• In the context of that assessment, it is, specifically, for the national court to determine whether unlawful gaming activities may constitute a problem in the Netherlands and whether the expansion of authorised and regulated activities would be liable to solve such a problem (Idem, point 29).

When it comes to the national licensing schemes, the ECJ also confirms that:

• "Article 49 EC must be interpreted as meaning that the principles of equal treatment and the consequent obligation of transparency are applicable (…) in the field of games of chance” (Betfair case C-203/08, point 62)

• “If a prior administrative authorisation scheme is to be justified even though it derogates from a fundamental freedom, it must be based on objective, non-discriminatory criteria known in advance, in such a way as to circumscribe the exercise of the authorities’ discretion so that it is not used arbitrarily” (Betfair case C-203/08, point 50)

_ _ _

Notes

(1) The preliminary ruling system (under Article 267 TFEU, ex-Article 234 of the EC Treaty) enables national courts to ensure uniform application of EU law in all the Member States. The ECJ has jurisdiction to give preliminary rulings on the interpretation of EU law in relation to specific legal questions raised by the national courts. In such rulings the Court makes every effort to give a reply which will be of assistance in resolving the dispute, but it is for the referring court to draw the appropriate conclusions from that reply in a final decision.

(2) A Green Paper released by the European Commission is a discussion document intended to stimulate debate and launch a process of consultation, at European level, on a particular topic. It may be followed by a White Paper, an official set of proposals for future EU legislation. A Green Paper on gambling is expected to be published by the European Commission in the autumn 2010.

(3) Infringement procedures brought by the European Commission (under Article 258 TFEU, ex-Article 226 of the EC Treaty) allow the ECJ to give a judgment with regard to the compliance of national legislations with EC law. Under such procedure the ECJ does not just give its interpretation of E law on specific selective questions but is able to have a broader analysis assessing as well the factual situation at stake. Seven Member States (Denmark, Finland, France, Sweden, Hungary, the Netherlands and Greece) are currently subject to an infringement procedure in relation to their gambling legislation and have already received a reasoned opinion, the last procedural step before the start of an infringement case at the ECJ.)


press release of EGBA